Just not cricket?

Controversy surrounding Sri Lankan cricket players participation in the Indian Premier League has again brought to the fore issues surrounding human rights abuses in Sri Lanka and the close links between that nations government and cricket board. It would be tempting to merely cite the old mantra of not mixing sport and politics, but when the Sri Lankan government is so entwined with Sri Lankan cricket, often exploiting it for propaganda purposes, it is impossible not to link the two.

The background to the issue is the brutal conclusion to the decades old Sri Lankan civil war in early 2009. The Sri Lankan army ruthlessly eliminated the separatist Tamil Tigers, in the process indiscriminately and at times deliberately at the expense of civilian life. Gordon Weiss’ book The Cage provides an excellent and comprehensive portrayal of the issues surrounding the war. Put simply though, the end of the war was the culmination of decades of discrimination against Tamils by the majority Sinhalese. So why the link to cricket? Quite simply, given the government’s role in Sri Lanka Cricket, the nation’s cricket board, it is impossible to divorce the Sri Lankan state from its cricket team. Former players Arjuna Ranatunga and Sanath Jayasuriya are both government MPs, whilst current player Ajantha Mendis was an artillery gunner who served during the war. All of these factors have led to the current fracas, whereby Sri Lankan players have been told they would be unable to play in matches in the city of Chennai, in the ethnically Tamil south Indian state of Tamil Nadu. This came abouts after the state’s Chief Minister noted that in light of prevailing anti Sinhalese atmosphere in the state, the players safety could not be guaranteed. This has led to outcry from figures such as Ranatunga, and the inevitable decrying of the mixing of politics and sport.

Quite frankly, this is simply unacceptable. This issue highlights the ongoing issues surrounding the Sri Lankan cricket team and its participation in international competition. It is clearly an instrument of the government and serves to further its propaganda goals, including by virtue of the nation hosting part of the 2011 World Cup. The attitude taken towards the team is quite frankly hypocritical. What the Sri Lankan government did and has done to the Tamil population, and indeed dissenting Sinhalese, in numerical terms has been far worse than atrocities perpetrated in apartheid South Africa, and more recently Zimbabwe, both of which attracted full or partial sporting boycotts. Those of us in democratic nations such as Australia, and others must ask serious questions as to why we continue to host the Sri Lankan cricket team, as well as touring there, when this practice continues to give legitimacy to a government which has yet to be punished for grave crimes against humanity. Hopefully the controversy surrounding the IPL shall again bring this travesty to the fore.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Just not cricket?

  1. redearthbluesky

    When living in China, I spoke to a few Chinese journalists about human rights and particularly the idea of political engagement with countries that violate human rights. (At the time, China was investing heavily in Sudanese oil.)

    Eventually, we came to an agreement that humans rights were something that developed in western countries over centuries and it was not practical to just expect them to appear overnight in other countries. Sanctions could therefore result in situations like Zimbabwe and North Korea where the government really doesn’t care. Before sanctions can work, a significant number of people need to have something to lose by them and that means they need a certain level of economic development. Therefore, helping cultures attain that development is the first step before any threat.

    Reply
    1. ramblingsofapoliticsstudent Post author

      I certainly agree on the point of the efficacy of sanctions. The unfortuante thing is, as I learnt, Sri Lanka has actually regressed. It in fact had a good legal system and a solid economy at independence, which has now been ruined by the greed and abuse of a select few. I suppose my more fundamental point was the blatant hypocrisy in not touring apartheid South Africa when what has been done to the Tamils is not only apartheid, but genocide.

      Reply
      1. redearthbluesky

        Like many former colonies, perhaps Sri Lanka suffered because it had the institutions but not the diversification of power than comes from a well developed middle class. It also suffered due to patriotism that was fueled by anti-colonial sentiment, as patriotism became a tool for critics to be silenced, corruption over looked.

        Post-modernism perhaps explains the sanctions on South Africa. The majority of Australian had Caucasian ancestry and the ruling class in South Africa did as well, so sanctions were a way of demonstrating Australia wasn’t racist. The same wouldn’t occur if putting sanctions on a group of people not considered to be the same race. To the contrary, the fear would be that we might be racist ourselves.

        This is probably where it might be better to approach the world in a humanistic frame of mind, not racial frame of mind.

      2. ramblingsofapoliticsstudent Post author

        That is quite a valid point, but from what I’ve read there still was a reasonable middle class of civil servants etc, and the nations decline had much more to do with friction stemming from the fact that the Tamil minority held many of these posts, which was resented by the Sinhala. In relation to South Africa, the point you raise is valid, but I feel that given that nations have had similar qualms about contact with Zimbabwe in recent years shows that this is a matter more about sporting politics than about race.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s